The 15 Best Mothman Gifts: For People Who Want to Know More

In the world of cryptids, there are some creatures which inspire more fear than others. The Mothman is one such creature. Based in the small town of Point Pleasant, West Virginia, the appearance of this strange creature foreshadowed a tragic event: the collapse of the New River Bridge and the resulting deaths of 46 people. It’s a tragic story which has captured many people’s imagination over the years — and it makes for some great mothman gifts.
There are few things that people love more than a good scare, especially when that scare comes from something that isn’t real. Mothman is one such monster, who has managed to maintain his fame for almost 50 years now. Read on to discover more about Mothman and our top 15 gift ideas for those who want to know more about this sinister creature…

This post may contain affiliate links. Check out the affiliate disclosure for more info. Thanks for your support! 

Mothman Tin Sign

Bestseller No. 1
Abstract Sign - Mothman 24068 Metal Tin Poster
  • High quality Abstract printed on Tin sign.
  • Approximate Size: 20*30cm (7.8"x11.8" inches)
  • Rolled and hemmed edges (for safe handling)

Reasonably priced at just under $10, this Mothman tin sign consisting of a quality sturdy metal material with high quality graphics is the ideal gift for any budding cryptozoologist! It is both humorous and unique, offering a focal point in any bathroom, office or mudroom. The 8×12 inch sizing makes it perfect for a number of applications without overwhelming the viewer. Most importantly, it is easily applied on any surface thanks to the pre-drilled corner holes that offer ideal placement! Whether shopping for that perfect gift or wanting a conversation starter, this Mothman tin sign is a reminder of a truly bygone era.

Mothman Blanket

Bestseller No. 1
Mothman Night Flannel Blanket Lightweight Cozy Bed Blankets Soft Throw Blanket Fit Couch Sofa...
  • Material: This Mothman Night Plush Blanket Is Made...
  • Cozy & Lightweight - Get Cozy And Lightweight With...
  • Versatile Usage : Plush And Warm Fleece Blankets...

Measuring 50 by 40 inches, this cozy Mothman throw blanket is both unique and offers versatility. Ideal for cold weather, this blanket is constructed of wholly breathable plush microfiber that enhances its cold weather appeal, while the quality craftsmanship speaks for itself! Snuggle up on your couch or cuddle with this cryptid blanket on your chair as it’s both lightweight and warm enough to replace your comforter during the summer months. Each blanket is also washing machine-friendly, meaning you can easily launder it in cold water with like colors or separately. Additionally, the fade-resistant and wrinkle-free exterior ensures that you get many years of faithful use out of this investment!

Mothman Coffee Mug

Bestseller No. 1
LookHUMAN Cute Mothman Pattern White 15 Ounce Ceramic Coffee Mug
  • Our 15-ounce Mug features large handles for easy...
  • Great gift idea for that special someone, a...
  • Designed and Printed in the USA

Cute and cuddly, this Mothman coffee mug can hold 15 ounces of your favorite beverage while also offering a conversation starter at the office! Constructed with careful attention to detail, the high-definition Mothman icon is both sweet and unique. Each mug offers durable versatility thanks to its ceramic construction that’s both lightweight and easy to grip while being hard-wearing. The sentiment, “Mothman Believes In You” serves as a fun and quirky reminder that we all need something uplifting from time-to-time. Whether you choose to gift this to a friend who believes in the paranormal, or you just want something unique for yourself, this is one mug that pack a punch!

Mothman Figure

Bestseller No. 1
Safari Ltd. Mythical Realms Collection - Spooky Mothman Figure - Non-toxic and BPA Free - Ages 3 and...
  • AN AMERICAN URBAN LEGEND: The Mothman was a...
  • A SPOOKY HISTORY: Described as a “man-sized”...
  • CHARACTERISTICS: This Mothman figure features many...

You’re going to have a lot of fun with this mothman figure. It’s a great piece to put on a shelf to show off and it can really be a great gift for people that are into stories about the creature. It’s a good idea to get this figure because it is made of high quality materials and will be a piece you can have on display for a very long time before you retire it. Always go with high quality figures and you are sure to enjoy them for as long as you want because figures like this are built to last!

Mothman Pin

Bestseller No. 1
Winks For Days Mothman Cryptid Creature Hard Enamel Lapel Pin
  • QUALITY MATTERS: Mothman Cryptid Creature is a...
  • SAFE AND SECURE: Each pin has 2 posts on the back...
  • UNIQUE ARTISTIC STYLE: We design each pin...

This cryptid mothman pin is the perfect combination of myth and fantasy delivering a quality lapel pin that turns heads! Manufactured from a durable yet sturdy black nickel material, it contains a colorful enameled image of the legendary mothman. Each lapel pin is constructed with the highest attention to detail, and the polished scratch-resistant surface makes it ideal to wear daily. Though only about 2 inches wide, the pin still packs enough punch to attract attention from afar while delivering the ultimate way to show creativity. Each pin has a solid and secure back with two pins that feature security rubber caps to protect all surfaces!

Mothman Earrings

Bestseller No. 1
FAADBUK Mothman Lover Gift Mothman Earrings Moth Insect Witch Spooky Monster Creepy Weird Funky...
  • Mothman Lover Gift - Looking for some cute...
  • Material – High Quality Stainless Steel;...
  • These earrings are perfect for the Halloween...

Nothing says unique like these specially constructed hypoallergenic Mothman earrings! Perfect for Halloween or year-round, keep your friends guessing as to where you got these pieces of unique jewelry. Each pair of earrings feature a solid metal rendition of Mothman with the iconic red eyes that are easily viewed from afar. Each piece of jewelry is ready for gifting thanks to the velvet gift bag it comes packaged in. Reasonably priced but still produced of high quality metal, these earrings are sure to be a hit for the cryptid lover in your life! Additionally, the stainless steel ear wires will prevent irritation or discoloration with prolonged use.

Mothman: The Facts Behind The Legend

SaleBestseller No. 1
Mothman: The Facts Behind The Legend
  • Used Book in Good Condition
  • Donnie Sergent Jr. (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)

Are you intrigued by the Mothman? Do you want to find out more about the Mothman? If the answer to these questions is yes, you will enjoy this paperback book. It packs in a ton of interviews and photographs. All the information in this book has been collected from a huge range of sources. The authors have carefully presented the facts as a fact and they allow the reader to make up their mind whether it is a fact or fiction. It is a popular book and an engaging read. If you like mysteries and would like to have a good time with a factual book, you’re going to enjoy this one.

Mothman Plush

Bestseller No. 1
Plush Toy Figure Toys Mothman Shape Hugging Pillow Soft Carton Character Stuffed Doll Birthday Gift...
  • 💛Durable: not easily deformed, resistant to...
  • 💙Soft and skin-friendly: plush toys, feel good...
  • 💜Cute shape: cute movie character design, fun...

Mothman’s fans come from all walks of life, and you’re never too young or old to enjoy a hug from the iconic legendary creature! This Mothman plush measures 30 cm tall, and though constructed with reinforced stitching and solid stuffing, it’s still completely huggable. The cartoon-like nature of the cryptid adds to its appeal, while the mesmerizing red eyes serve as the focal point of the plush. Each stuffed animal is manufactured with careful attention to detail, and the non-wrinkling plush material can withstand many years of wear and tear! Ideal as a gift for birthdays, Christmas or just-because, this is that unique surprise for virtually anyone in your life.

The Mothman Prophecies

Bestseller No. 1
The Mothman Prophecies
  • Amazon Prime Video (Video on Demand)
  • Mark Pellington, Richard Gere, Lucinda Jenney...
  • Mark Pellington (Director) - Gary Lucchesi...

In this supernatural thriller, John Klein, a Washington Post reporter, is inadvertently drawn to a Point Pleasant, a small West Virginia town bedeviled by a series of unexplained phenomena. This happens two years after Klein loses his wife in a car accident, immediately after she experiences a strange moth-like vision. What Klein discovers defies simple explanation. He finds there is a connection between his late wife’s sketches of an eerie apparition and the events in Point Pleasant, and everything leads to the conclusion that it all seems to predict impending disasters. Are there supernatural forces behind the strange occurrences, and what awaits this small town in West Virginia? John Klein is hellbent on unraveling the truth and preventing something terrible from happening.

Eyes of the Mothman

Bestseller No. 1
Eyes of the Mothman
  • Amazon Prime Video (Video on Demand)
  • James Beichler, John Frick, Timothy Frick (Actors)
  • Matthew J. Pellowski (Director) - Red Line Studios...

The Eyes of the Mothman is a fascinating feature-length documentary directed by Matthew J. Pellowski. It attempts to uncover the truth behind the unsolved mystery of The Mothman, a strange creature often thought to be supernatural or demonic. The creature was sighted by 4 friends in 1966 and was believed to be responsible for 46 tragic deaths and leaving hundreds more traumatized and emotionally scarred for life. The production is very professional, incorporating nonintrusive and wonderfully woven narration, interviews, and local history with legends. The audio is uniformly clear, the video crisp and well edited. It is a great selection for fans of the paranormal and urban legends

Merry Mothmas Shirt

Bestseller No. 1
Mothman Christmas - Merry Mothmas Funny Moth Man Xmas Santa Premium T-Shirt
  • This cool Mothman Christmas, full moon Santa hat...
  • This West Virginia cryptid monster design makes...
  • This premium t-shirt is made of lightweight fine...

The merry mothmas shirt is sure to entertain those that see it being worn by someone. It’s a good fit for the holiday season, or just for someone to wear that is a fan of the rumors about the Mothman. If you know someone that is into theories related to this kind of thing, they are sure to really get a kick out of this shirt. You can buy it in most sizes so it can be worn by pretty much anyone. It is made of breathable materials so it can be worn during the summer and will not be too difficult to keep cool in.

Retro Flying Mothman T-Shirt

Bestseller No. 1
Someday We'll All Be Dead Retro Existential Dread Toon Style T-Shirt
  • Nothing matters, so live your life. Funny...
  • Featuring a vintage retro sun cartoon style with...
  • Lightweight, Classic fit, Double-needle sleeve and...

If you’re into cryptids or know someone that is, this retro flying mothman t-shirt is a fantastic idea to invest in. It’s made of materials that are sure to stand up to washing and you’ll enjoy the retro graphic that takes you back in time. You’re going to be able to get the shirt in many sizes so you can get something that fits well and that you can show off to others. Get it for your wardrobe or you can get it as a gift. It also comes with a tearaway label so you can get rid of the annoying label when you first get the shirt.

The Mothman Prophecies Audiobook

Bestseller No. 1
The Mothman Prophecies
  • Audible Audiobook
  • John A. Keel (Author) - Craig Wasson (Narrator)
  • English (Publication Language)

When it comes to gaining a comprehensive and all-encompassing look at the apparition known as the Mothman, John Keel provides a masterful account of his experiences in Point Pleasant during 1966. The Mothman Prophecies delivers a memorable and gripping auditory experience in this charming audiobook taking a look at how domestic animals were slaughtered while a real-life nightmare unfolded in this small town.

This audiobook offers a look at the ups and downs of Point Pleasant during this period including the natural emotion associated with the situation. It uncovers hidden elements John Keel noticed during this period including the experiences of others.

Mothman Socks

Bestseller No. 1
PIOKNGY Mothman Stripes And Stuffs Socks Casual Socks Sports Socks Fun Work Socks for Women girls...
  • ★ 97% Polyester 3% Spandex, Unisex One Size For...
  • ★ High-Quality, Soft, Comfortable,...
  • ★Make Your Socks Look Best In The Years To Come....

These unisex Mothman socks are both fun and completely useful as a gift or for personal use! Each pair of socks has a solid purple background with the legendary Mothman’s silhouette thrown across the surface. The polyester/spandex construction ensures that the socks are breathable but won’t shrink or distort in the wash. Fashionable yet completely nostalgic, these socks are ideal for complementing any number of outfits while offering a warm and comforting reminder that we’re neve truly alone! The socks have limited care instructions and are easily laundered in your washing machine, while their design is unisex in nature and can offer the perfect gift for anyone.

Mothman Onesie

Bestseller No. 1
Mothman Holding A Teddy Bear Baby Onesie Outfit Bodysuits One-Piece, Multicolor, 24 Months
  • HOW TO ORDER: Click "Customize Now" to Select the...
  • Printed in the USA. Soft, breathable cotton keeps...
  • 4.5 oz., 100% combed ringspun cotton. Wide...

The Mothman one-piece bodysuit is a unisex baby product that is made from 100% combed-ringspun cotton, displaying an image of Mothman holding a teddy bear baby. The breathable, soft material is comfy to wear and will retain it shape for many washes. When ordering this product click the “Customize Now” tab to select the size, color and type. The water-based ink (printed in the USA) is eco-friendly which makes these bodysuits the ideal gift for a baby shower, a birthday, or a Christmas gift. The durable fabric is machine washable, making these oniesies perfect for indoor play or crawling around or as an everyday wear item.

Scroll to Top